Select Prop Firm

What Is a Consistency Rule

A consistency rule is a trading condition used by some prop firms to ensure that a trader’s profit is generated in a steady and repeatable manner rather than from a single oversized trade or outlier day. It is designed to confirm that a trader can produce results through controlled execution across multiple sessions. This rule may be enforced during the evaluation phase, the funded phase, or both, depending on the firm and account type. When present, the consistency rule becomes an important part of how progression or payout eligibility is determined.

How Firms Apply It

Firms typically measure consistency by analyzing the distribution of profit across trades or trading days. The goal is to prevent traders from relying on a single large position that may not reflect long-term sustainability or sound risk management. Each firm sets its own standards for what qualifies as consistent. Some may allow up to 30 percent of the total profit to come from a single day, while others may use different thresholds or guidelines. These thresholds can vary by account size, evaluation model, or funding stage. Because there is no universal percentage applied across the industry, it is important for traders to review each firm's policy closely.

Consistency rules do not usually result in a hard breach of the account if violated. Instead, traders are typically required to continue trading until their overall results reflect a more balanced distribution. In practice, this means that even after reaching the profit target, a trader may need to log additional trading days with smaller, steadier profits in order to bring the account back into alignment with the consistency requirement. This process delays account progression but does not reset or invalidate the account unless other rules are also broken.

Real Consistency Rule Example

Consider a trader completing a $50,000 evaluation with a $3,000 profit target. Over several days, the trader earns small gains but then makes a single $2,600 profit in one trade on day five. This one trade now accounts for over 85 percent of total profits. If the firm applies a consistency rule requiring that no more than 50 percent of the profit can come from one day or one trade, the trader would not yet qualify for funding. However, the trader can continue trading in smaller, more consistent increments until the large trade becomes a smaller percentage of the total. For instance, if the trader continues and brings the total profit to $5,000, the $2,600 trade would then account for just over 50 percent, potentially meeting the threshold.

Evaluating Performance Over Time

Some firms track consistency across average daily profit, the number of profitable days, or the percentage of profit generated by the largest trade. Others may monitor it more loosely, with manual review during payout requests or account promotions. In funded stages, consistency requirements may be applied before allowing a payout or scaling opportunity. These reviews are not always disclosed upfront and may happen after the trader requests an account upgrade or withdrawal. Even in cases where there is no fixed numerical formula, the trader is expected to demonstrate control, balance, and a clear trading process.

Summary

A consistency rule is used to verify that trading profits are earned through a repeatable and steady process rather than from one-time outcomes. It may apply to evaluations, funded accounts, or both, and the specific thresholds differ across firms and account types. Violating the consistency rule does not typically cause a breach, but it may delay progression or payout eligibility until results become more evenly distributed. Traders should be aware of this rule, track their performance distribution closely, and maintain a mindset focused on repeatability rather than isolated wins.